Football NewsBBC SportUnverified source· 21 Sept 2026
Brobbey's Hat-Trick in Defeat Joins Rare Premier League List
Brian Brobbey scored three but still ended up on the losing side, becoming just the fifth player to do so in Premier League history.


B. Brobbey
player
Player
Brian Brobbey
Match
Manchester City 5-3 Sunderland
Competition
Premier League
Occurrence
5th player, 6th time
What happened. Sunderland striker Brian Brobbey scored a hat-trick in his side's 5-3 defeat at Manchester City. He is the first player to score a Premier League hat-trick in a losing cause since 2007.
- Brobbey is only the fifth different player to achieve the feat in Premier League history.
- Roque Santa Cruz was the last to do so, for Blackburn in a 5-3 loss at Wigan in December 2007.
- Matt Le Tissier is the only player to have scored hat-tricks in two Premier League defeats.
Brobbey's achievement highlights a rare piece of Premier League history, joining a small group of players who scored three in a losing effort.
In this story
More to read

CaughtOffside
Man United face major hurdle in January pursuit of £50m-rated Premier League star

GiveMeSport
Premier League Issue Statement Over Sunderland Penalty vs Arsenal

CaughtOffside
Sunderland value monster striker at £50m – and could get a lot more as interest grows

CaughtOffside
Report: Sunderland star set for 2027 exit

