Football NewsSky SportsUnverified source· 15 Sept 2026
Webb: Foden red justified, Fernandes escaped yellow
Pro Ref chief Howard Webb backs Phil Foden's Manchester derby red card but reveals Bruno Fernandes should have been cautioned.

Referee
Michael Oliver
VAR
Matt Donohue
Match
Man City 1-0 Man Utd
Red card
Phil Foden (violent conduct)
What happened. Howard Webb supported the decision to send off Phil Foden for violent conduct in the Manchester derby. Webb also revealed that Bruno Fernandes should have been cautioned for a 'petulant' kick but VAR could not intervene.
- Foden kicked out at Fernandes after being fouled by the Man Utd captain.
- Fernandes escaped punishment despite initiating the incident with a kick.
- VAR discussed a possible penalty for Man Utd during the review.
“Who has been sent off and for what?”
— VAR official Matt Donohue
The incident highlights VAR's limitations in retrospectively punishing players for off-ball actions.
In this story
More to read

Mirror Football
Phil Foden branded 'stupid' for Bruno Fernandes kick as Wayne Rooney agrees on red card verdict

Mirror Football
Bruno Fernandes' lamentable behaviour in Phil Foden incident not befitting of Man Utd captain

BBC Sport
Fernandes and Foden should have been sent off - Maresca

Sky Sports
Keane disagrees with Foden red card as pundits criticise Fernandes' role

