Carragher: Carrick lacks stardust to win Man United titles

Liverpool legend warns United fans that Michael Carrick's steady hand may not be enough for the biggest trophies.

What happened. Jamie Carragher said Michael Carrick lacks the 'stardust' to win the Premier League or Champions League with Manchester United, despite his good job so far.

• Carrick led United to third place and Champions League return last season.
• Carragher suggests United may need a Champions League-winning manager later.
• Carragher believes United missed out on Mateus Fernandes due to £85m price.

“I personally just don't think Michael Carrick's got that stardust as a manager to win a Champions League or a Premier League.”

— Jamie Carragher

Carrick's permanent appointment has sparked optimism, but Carragher urges caution before the 2026-27 season.

In this story

Manchester UnitedMichael Carrick

More to read

BBC Sport

Signings impress but squad issues remain - learnings from Man Utd's summer

GiveMeSport

Man Utd Discuss Move To Sign Igor Matanovic

GiveMeSport

Man Utd Can Sign Three More Players Before Transfer Sindow Shuts

Mirror Football

Michael Carrick sends Man Utd stars demand after AC Milan loss - 'No excuses'

Mirror Football

Man Utd new signing sends message to Michael Carrick during private friendly

Mirror Football

Man Utd news: Michael Carrick issues transfer statement as Ibrahim Mbaye decision made