Football NewsBBC SportUnverified source· 16 Aug 2026
Community Shield winners rarely lift Premier League
Winning the Community Shield might feel good, but history says it rarely leads to league glory.


Arsenal
team
Match
Arsenal vs Manchester City
Date
Sunday
Venue
Principality Stadium, Cardiff
History
Only 8 of 34 winners won the league
What happened. Ahead of Sunday's Community Shield between Arsenal and Manchester City, stats show that winning the curtain-raiser rarely leads to a Premier League title.
- Only one of the past 15 Community Shield winners became champions.
- Since 1992, losing finalists have won more league titles (10) than winners (8).
- Last year's winners Crystal Palace finished 15th in the league.
The match could hint at the season ahead, but history suggests caution.
In this story
More to read

Arseblog
Community Shield preview: Still pre-season, but a bit more important

The Guardian
Community Shield buildup, Championship and club friendly updates – matchday live

Metro Football
Why winning the Community Shield could be a bad omen for Arsenal and Manchester City

Mirror Football
Mikel Arteta fired Community Shield warning as predictions made for Arsenal vs Man City

